It’s a change in nomenclature that’s come a bit out of the blue over the last few years. The forces appear to be aligning to gradually push the word “Doctor” out of the center and towards the periphery of healthcare. Whether we are talking about administrative communication or healthcare information technology order entry—it seems that we are no longer “Physicians” or even “Clinicians”, but we have all become grouped together under the non-specific term of “Provider”. This is a huge change, and from what I’ve seen has gone barely challenged or even questioned. Even calling a pharmacy a few years ago has changed from “Doctors press 2 now” to “Prescribers press 2 now”! Now I make no judgment about my non-Physician colleagues, who are increasingly providing care at the frontlines of medicine. It’s not about them, or what they do (in fact, “Nurse Practitioner” or “Physician Assistant” sounds far more professional than “Provider” anyway!). The issue is with the term “Provider” and how a group of highly trained physicians who have in most cases spent well over a decade in training have allowed themselves to be grouped under this umbrella term. Why does this matter? Well, there’s a lot in a name. Can you imagine another group of professionals—whether they be attorneys, accountants or dentists—allowing themselves to be lumped together under terms like “Legal Provider”, “Finance Provider” or “Dental Care Provider”? Unlikely. It’s so non-specific, and is used almost anywhere including referring to “Cable TV providers”, “Electricity providers” or “Telephone providers”! It’s a pattern in life that if you want to lower the power and clout of a group of people, start first by changing what you call them, and replace a respected title with a murky one. In fact, I am equally surprised by how so many of my Physician colleagues have jumped on the bandwagon, especially those in leadership positions. I’ve seen them openly be in a room surrounded by their physician colleagues and talk about how many “Providers” are on-call for the weekend or how many “Providers” are joining the new group (even though it’s all physicians).
So here’s a suggestion, if we mustn’t refer to doctors as doctors anymore—why not use a slightly better term than “Provider”? How about “Clinician”? At least that sounds remotely more scientific and distinguished?! In the meantime, here’s how you can avoid becoming a “Provider”:
- When you are emailed by an administrator who is referring to you and your fellow colleagues as “Providers”—correct them immediately and never use that word to describe yourself or your physician group
- If you are involved in the design of any new system’s wording, whether it’s on the computer or on a written form, if “Physician” is really too specific, encourage use of the word “Clinician” instead
- Ask your hospital IT department why the word “Provider” is everywhere across the IT system and politely ask them if they can change the wording
- When you are filling out any paperwork that is asking for the “Provider’s signature”, add in the word “Physician” or “MD”
- Be proud to call yourself a doctor!
We belong to an ancient profession. The word doctor is over two thousand years old, aptly derived from the Latin doctus, meaning to teach or instruct. Physician was used traditionally to describe a medical doctor, and King Henry VIII granted the first charter to form the Royal College of Physicians in 1518. In almost every country in the world, a medical doctor is considered to be among the most noble and prestigious professions, the title only conferred after one of the most rigorous university courses in existence. It is a privilege and honor to be one. Every good physician worked hard to become a fine doctor and clinician. If doctors don’t allow themselves to be called a “Provider”, they won’t be one. If however, doctors allow themselves to become a “Provider” at every turn, then that is what they shall be.
“In the changing healthcare environment, doing my best to advocate for great patient care, physician autonomy, reduced bureaucracy, less time with computers and more with our patients”- Dr Dhand
Suneel Dhand is a physician, author, speaker and healthcare consultant. He has experience in a number of different healthcare environments, having worked up and down the East coast and also internationally. His specialty areas include hospital QI, improving the patient experience, and optimizing healthcare IT. “He is the Founder & Director” of MangoWell, an organization and consulting service that helps hospitals and healthcare professionals improve the quality of hospital care. MangoWell’s most recent publication, “The Ultimate Patient Advocate in Your Pocket”, is designed to help hospitalized patients.
Also follow Suneel’s blog at: www.HealthcareImprove.com
hi. Thank god in India they are still called as doctors.
Yes they area brred apart because they directly deal with the Human Body
Raju Parekh
Came across your article. Thanks for raising this issue. I think that there has been a concerted effort in the industry to weaken the authority and influence of physicians, mostly by administrators, especially in so called integrated health systems. I think that we should stick with physicians, thought. Not sure “clinician” does that much more than “provider”. I am a neuroradiologist and have noticed in our voice recognition application where the ordering “provider’s” name is written, there is no designation of what the person is whether MD, NP or PA. I always have to ask the clerk or nurse who answers the phone when I am calling reports to know to whom I am speaking.
Thank you for your attention to a problem central to the meaning of healthcare. Our traditional realationships with patients are to be focused around diagnosis (to know across or through ) and teaching the artful combinations of both medical care and mindful living. I suspect the task can be done by doctors given sufficient time to create a relationship with patients. I feel certain it cannot be done well in 6-10 minutes by a provider to a “covered commercial life”.